Simply Splendid

So I was tooling around eBay last week when I noticed a very interesting player ledger kept by Topps back in the pre-digital days.  This one knocked my (Red) Sox off almost immediately:

As far as 1950's Topps hoped-for star power went, Williams was about as impressive a get as you could wish for at Bush Terminal. You will note the main section of the ledger starts in 1957, which at first struck me as odd since Ted famously kicked of with Topps in 1954 as the alpha and omega of that set after signing with the boys from Brooklyn. 

You can see Ted was signed at the end of December 1953 which totally tracks.  He had a five-year deal, which also tracks, as his last appearance with Topps as a player was in the 1958 set and he was off to Fleer for 1959.  Before that, he was in a real potpourri of issues starting with his 1939 Play Ball card and an R303-A Goudey premium. National releasers Bowman snagged him in 1951 but not in 1952, when he was appearing in the muddy looking Berk Ross set, the more colorful Red Man tobacco offering and on some Star Cal decals (a highly underrated set IMHO). He ended up being recalled by the Marines by the end of April '52 and then was a no show in terms of 1953 cards, except as part of the also underrated Canadian Exhibit set due to a late July mustering out. Topps then snapped him up.

However, a closer look at the upper right corner reveals the story there, and then some. Here, I blew it up for easier eyeballing:

Take a look at the box under SIGNED (K); Ted's Topps deal was arranged through his agent, F.J. Corcoran. Whatever deal Corcoran worked out with Topps must have been exclusive for gum cards and ultimately led to two Jimmy Piersall cards and and no "official" Williams cards for Bowman in 1954, although they certainly sold off what they could in packs once ceased-and-desisted. Corcoran can be considered the one of the first true sports agents - possibly even the first - coming to it through the world of golf, a sport with which Williams was well acquainted. We'll come back to him shortly. 

Those five years with Topps saw The Kid lead off three sets (1954, 1957 and 1958) and his time with them was his longest sustained run with any card company. It's also worth noting (again) Williams doesn't have a line entry on the ledger until 1957, when he received $450 from Topps, a significant premium compared to the standard amount of roughly $125 other players made.  Although they had a rudimentary system in place already, 1957 was the first year Topps prepared a merchandise catalog for their ballplayers to choose from if they didn't take the offered cash stipend. Ted would be back with Topps as a manager in 1969 but as you can see, he was getting the standard $250 per season for a new contract in effect at that time upon his return, plus the standard $5 in "steak money" for signing. He took the merch thereafter.

Somewhat, but not completely, surprisingly, there was a bit of a wrinkle to all this, namely this letter forwarded by friend o'the Archive Tony DeMarzio, which was sent by Sy Berger to Corcoran memorializing an extension for Williams for 1958. Maybe the ledger card was only created just around that time, or maybe something else was at play, like an option in the original deal. The October 1st date may be significant as the championship season, which may have been how the original agreement referenced duration, ended on September 29th, with the World Series to follow:

As for F.J. Corcoran, he had several other famous baseball players as clients.  Of particular interest is Stan Musial, another ballplayer whose past reveals a wide range of regional issues and some on the national stage, capped by a 1953 Bowman card. Stan the Man signed a deal and joined up with Topps around the time Williams was exiting in late 1958, only appearing on an All Star card in the nosebleed section. Topps was so excited, they tripled their fun:

(Courtesy Heritage Auctions)

Musial would have Topps cards every year thereafter until he retired following the 1963 season; given the probable July-ish production date for the '58 highs, he seems like a signee whose previous exclusive contract (with Rawlings, I believe) had just expired. I wonder if he too got a long term deal?

An old auction lot had some enlightening Musial correspondence with Corcoran circa 1950:

(Courtesy RR Auction)

An interesting comment within those letters concerned Stan returning a 1950 Bowman contract unsigned, via a letter dated February 26, 1950 . That changed of course but you can also see the Rawlings deal was his most lucrative at the time. He did OK with Wheaties too, and an outfit called Palm Beach (maybe the Florida town?):

I'd really like to track down Musial's Topps player ledger and also dive into his deals via Corcoran, I'll start digging in earnest soon.

The Express Way

Spinning through some more Topps Vault scans today kids, which brings us to Alvin, Texas, via Brooklyn and Queens. No suspense then, as you have probably all recognized Nolan Ryan as the subject of our post du jour. Specifically, we'll be looking at his gift and merchandise preferences sometimes taken as compensation from Topps.

Here's Ryan's 1969 response to Topps concerning his compensation for the year:

Love how he addresses Sy Berger informally!  Ryan indeed took the check:

This busy reverse shows how they did things back in the long, long ago, in the far, far away:

Those 1969 examples were poorly scanned I'm afraid, but his 1970 check came though crystal clear:

Looks like Sy, or maybe his secretary, was personally signing the player checks, at least those going to Ryan. You can see on the reverse here that signing the check became an acceptance of the "extention" contract with Topps. It was, and remains, a common practice in the business world to have an endorsed check memorialize an acceptance of contractual terms. It's worth mentioning too there no was spell check back then kids! 

This ledger card spans Ryan's rookie card season through his final Topps card and offers a complete look at his choices. He took a furniture set in exchange for his initial cash compensation in 1968 and I'm guessing it's because he had to furnish his home, either in New York or back home in Alvin. Baumritter Furniture eventually became known as Ethan Allan and they are renowned for their Mid Century Modern look these days. 

After the furniture arrived and then following two years of checks, the flamethrowing righty eventually decided to go after some specific merchandise instead of taking the money offered by Topps. He took an option for a Nikkormat camera in 1971, which was a consumer version of what were then professional level Nikon's.  Three years later he got another one, this time with a case.  He had to pay Topps $75 for that setup, a practice that was followed by the company for a long time when a player overtopped his allotment. As befits his later career as a banker, he took the cash in all other years.

UPDATE 10/19/25: Reader Bo noted the 1970 check was deposited by Shea Stadium concessionaire Harry M. Stevens. Ryan didn't endorse it "For Deposit Only" like he did in 1969 so he must have had it cashed at the ballpark.  I wonder if that perk was something commonplace with ballplayers? Also, Keith Olbermann advised the handwriting on Ryan's two camera choices on the player record belongs to Topps Sports Dept. jack of all trades Bill Haber, a key figure there, in the hobby and to baseball history in general.

Give 'Em The Bird

Two or three years ago I posted about a large index card that showed a bunch of information concerning Jim Palmer, specifically what he received from Topps each year in the form of cash or merchandise, in exchange for the right to use his image on their products.  Palmer had a long career and his card had been annexed, with a small additional piece stapled onto it.  It turns out that little stapled flip was concealing some good information about the process Topps used to sign and retain baseball players.  Thanks to a Friend o' a Friend o' the Archive Chuck Wolf, name one Andrew W., there is a player payment card we can examine that covered to totality of Mark "The Bird" Fidrych's Topps career.

Fidrych, who was tagged with his nickname by his first professional manager due to his resemblance to Big Bird on Sesame Street, had an extremely parabolic major league career and attained lasting fame in 1976, putting together a rookie campaign that ranked with the best of any postwar pitcher but also gained attention due to an eccentric personality and mound presence.  He made the Tigers out of Spring Training but didn't really get going until May, when he uncorked a string of stellar starts.  He would talk to the baseball before pitches, excessively groom the mound like a Bonsai garden, circle around it and then shoo away groundskeepers who came near it. He became a media sensation almost overnight, back in a time when that actually required some effort, made the All Star team (starting but losing the game) and ended up finishing second in the AL Cy Young race to, of all people, the aforementioned Jim Palmer.

He was also the 1976 AL Rookie of the Year and of course made the Topps Rookie All Star team. This would earn him the distinction of being , I believe, the only player with a Topps All Star card featuring a Topps rookie trophy symbol:

He hurt his knee early in 1977, still pitching well but his arm went dead and he was never the same and threw his last major league pitch in 1980, then pitched in the minors for three more years and that was it.  If you want more of the story, his ledger card at Topps tells it well:

You can see at the top left he got sent down in July of '78, likely for a couple of rehab starts after missing the vast majority of the season. He did not pitch well the next two years and was demoted to AAA by Detroit in 1981, which ended any interest Topps had in him.

The top right portion of the card details a few things.  Firstly, once he signed a professional contract in 1974, Topps gave him $5 in "steak money" in exchange for his contractual rights to appear on cards sold with bubble gum. They did this for thousands of minor leaguers.  Fidrych then  got a $75 extension bonus for a two year period in 1975, which roughly corresponds to his promotion to AAA ball that year.  That extension bonus was referenced in the Jim Palmer post and I'll show a relevant excerpt for the Topps Gift Catalog provided to players that appeared here previously (this one if for 1973-74:

Once you made the majors (and stayed on a roster for 30 consecutive days), an annual $250 payment was made by Topps and your extension bonus kicked; I think it took a little longer in the 60's to extend but I guess the players (or more accurately, Marvin Miller) got better at negotiating with Topps. Fidrych got his for 1976 and '77 then they gave another two year extension in 1978. You could combine payments for gifts, take the cash or bank what you had.  These lovely and underpaid ladies kept track of it all for Topps:

Sometimes players picked gifts that exceeded their bank or annual allotment.  They would then write a check to Topps for the difference; Jim Palmer did it so why not The Bird?!

You can also see Fidrych was delinquent for a time, likely due to his thinking he would get his extension bonus for 1981!  Somewhat tragically, you can see he was taking some machinery as gifts, possibly as he was buying a farm, where he would be killed in an accident in 2009. He also took some state of the art audio equipment prior to that. It's fascinating to me how all of this dovetails and this ledger shows the sad arc of his career.